Since then, I have been on a quest to find an equally comparable cookie. Today, Cameron and I tried Superfood Quinoa Cookies by Desi from the Unconventional Kitchen. The recipe called for "fresh ground wonderflour" which is equal parts barley, brown rice, and spelt. Barley is one of the gluten grains, so we replaced the wonderflour with Almond Flour. (We're not intolerant or anything; we're just trying to not use as much gluten.) We also used wax paper in a regular jelly pan and a silpat. We cooked them with the dough at room temperature and refrigerated. Instead of butter we used coconut oil. And we used "turbinado" = raw cane sugar.
The Superfood Quinoa Cookie
Recipe:1 C coconut oil
1 C turbinado
1 C coconut sugar
2 eggs
1 t salt
1 t baking powder
1/2 T vanilla (1.5 t)
3 1/2 C almond flour
1/2 package mini chocolate chips
1/2 cup cooked quinoa
1 cup coco nibs (optional)
1/2 cup shredded unsweetened coconut
1 cup walnuts chopped
"Directions
Place soft butter and sugars in bosch bowl with cookie paddles. Whip until creamy, add eggs and whip until well blended. Add salt and baking powder with flour. (The original recipe said to add the soda - not sure if she made a mistake, but we just went with the baking powder). Mix well and add remaining ingredients, mixing well again. Scoop into a parchment lined cookies sheet. Bake in a 350 degree oven for 10 minutes or until light brown. Do not over bake, cookies are better slightly undercooked and cooled to remain soft." (I found that I had to take them out of the oven just as the edges were turning brown and let them cool right on the pan. If I tried to spatula them off right out of the oven or even 5 minutes out of the oven, they fell apart - probably because there was no gluten?)
Cam (with a freshly painted Easter Rabbit face) showing off the fruits of our labor. The cookie on the left was cooked on the silpat. The one of the right was cooked on wax paper and a jelly pan. I think the fiberglass in the silpat had a weird affect on the coconut oil. Not totally sure, but both batches on the silpat turned out like that. Cooking the dough at different temperatures didn't seem to have a huge effective on the final product. The silpat cookies seemed a little more melted when the dough was first refrigerated.
Cameron liked them very much. A little sweet for my taste. The coconut oil made them really moist, but lef them a little "oily." The coconut oil was on my hands after handling them. Next time, I might cut back on the sugar a bit and may try to cook with some good butter and the wonderflour Desi recommends.
A final note: they are good cookies, and pretty healthy. Similar taste to oatmeal cookies; our's had a small hint of coconut. But..... still not as good as Summer's Cowboy cookies. The quest continues.
Much thanks to Desi for the recipe.